clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Big East Football If Every Team Were A Judge From Chopped

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

via <a href=""></a>

If you've been paying attention, I'm a bit of a sucker for cooking shows. MasterChef, Hell's Kitchen, Top Chef, Next Food Network name it, I'm watching it. What's weird is that I'm not much of a cook. I can make a damn good omelet and you haven't had nachos until you've had Sean Keeley's World Famous Nachos Grande (the key is layering). Beside that, I don't have a clue. If you want someone to sous-vide a duck breast, serve it on a bed of parsnip puree and add a dollop of crème fraiche, I'm not your guy. But I'm happy to watch a complete stranger do it.

One of the best shows in the lot is Chopped. If you're not familiar, four chefs are given a mystery box that contains four random items. Those items usually have nothing to do with one another, like duck livers, cotton candy, taco shells and braeburn apples. Each chef then has to create the best appetizer possible and it must include those four ingredients in some form. Three chefs move on to the next mystery box to create an entree and then the two remaining chefs battle it out to create a dessert with the final mystery box.

The best part of the show are the judges, a collection of celebrity and top-level chefs who take everything way too seriously and nitpick every dish in a way that makes Top Chef seem like playtime.

Anyway, I never figured I'd talk about Chopped here until I saw it mentioned in a Drew Magary column and now a Bill Simmons mailbag. As far as I'm concerned, that's the sports blog tipping point for Chopped. And so...

Big East Football Teams If They Were Judges From Chopped



Cincinnati Bearcats - Marcus Samuelsson

Everyone's confused how that guy ended up with that name just like how everyone's confused how that school ended up in the Big East.

Both originally from strange and inhospitable landscapes (Ethopia/Cincinnati).

Both saw a meteoric rise to fame, both have failed to make notable appearances in recent seasons.

His most recent restaurant is called Red Rooster Harlem. That's also Zach Collaros' favorite play to call in the four-WR set.

Marcus once said to a contestant, "I want you to come up here and taste the beautiful bitter melon and I want to watch your facial expression." The look on that chef's face mirrored the look on Cincy fans' faces when Brian Kelly took the Notre Dame job.



Connecticut - Scott Conant

Both were born in Connecticut but fancy themselves New York City-folk.

Conant was a top restauranteur and TV personality, reaching great heights as a judge on Chopped. He then traded that in for a hosting gig on 24 Hour Restaurant Battle, which is decidedly-less cool and more boring than Chopped.

UConn had become a top Big East football program, winning the Big East title with Randy Edsall. They then traded him for Paul Pasqualoni, who is decidedly-less cool and more boring than Edsall.

Conant has an aversion to raw onions that borders on ludicrous. One would imagine the people of Connecticut find serving raw onions "too ethnic," eat only cooked onions.

Conant has a reputation for being cantankerous and cranky, snapping at those he's judging. Just know.



Louisville - Ted Allen

Allen is technically not a judge, though he does get to sample the dishes. Louisville is technically not a football school, though it does get to sample football from time to time.

Allen always has a pained look of sorrow on his face whenever he has to chop anyone. Louisville fans have that same look on their face anytime you mention the word "Kragthorpe."

Ted is a former Queer Eye host, where he was surrounded by people in flamboyant clothing. Louisville has Rick Pitino, who dresses like this.



Pittsburgh - Amanda Freitag

Imminently-talented, Freitag can, at times, look extremely hot (especially right after she takes a bite). Other times...not so much. Always stocked with talent, Pittsburgh can, at times, look like they're ready to take control of the Big East. Most of the time...not so much.

She usually sits in the middle of the judging table. Pitt usually ends up in the middle of the Big East standings.

In the Chopped: All-Stars Challenge, she came up short against stiff competition. Do I really need to write the Pittsburgh version of that?

Rutgers - Chris Santos

The self-appointed "bad boy" of the show/conference.

He/Rutger fans seems to enjoy pointing out everyone else's flaws.

As if some kind of karmic justice from on high, Santos always seems to end up with a hair or uncooked piece of food in his dish. As if some kind of karmic justice from on high, Schiano always seems to look like he just ate a hair or uncooked piece of food.

Santos is said to have his eye on the national scene, with restaurants planned in Las Vegas, Los Angeles and Miami. Rutgers is said to have an eye on the national scene, with do-whatever-it-takes offers out to the Big Ten, ACC and SEC.

Neither showed up last season.



South Florida - Aaron Sanchez

He hates it when you incorrectly refer to Latin dishes (not chilies, CHEE-LAYS), USF hates it when you point out there's nothing "south Florida" about South Florida.

His name must always be pronounced "Ah-RONE SAN-CHEZZZZZ."One of the original options for naming USF was Ponce de Leon University, which you probably would have had to pronounce as, "PONS DEY LEY-ONNNN."

During Chopped: All-Stars, he used a can opener on a can that had a pull-off lid. I'm 95% sure that's how all USF fans drink their Coors Light.

If you were to ask USF fans what they thought when the school hired Skip Holtz, they would all tell you...


Syracuse - Geoffrey Zakarian

Born elsewhere, Zakarian seems to want to embody New York City. Syracuse will fight anyone who doesnt agree they are New York's College Team.

His style is described as "modern, dynamic American." One could describe Doug Marrone in the same exact way.

There's a pompousness and smarminess to the way he judges, whether it's intended or not. Syracuse fans can come off as pompous and smarmy, especially if you bring up 1959, 1987 and the Donovan McNabb Era.

Geoffrey won his first executive chef position at the landscape-changing Restaurant 44. Did you hear me? I said Restaurant 44!

Zakarian recently declared bankruptcy. Syracuse football declared bankruptcy between 2005-2008.

West Virginia - Marc Murphy

His signature dish is called the "Ditch Dog," which also happens to be Dana Holgorsen's high school nickname.

Murphy has the innate ability to always find something in every dish to nitpick. West Virginia fans have the innate ability to make everything out to be an attack on them.

His restaurants are known for their highly untraditional wine lists. Dana Holgorsen is known for his highly untraditional consumption of win, beer, hard liquor, aperatifs and moonshine six nights a week.

Murphy is often referred to as "a pioneer of casual upscale dining." West Virginia...uh...their mascot kinda looks like a pioneer.

TCU - Alex Guarnaschelli

The most feared judge on the panel. Alex has murdered untold contestants with a simple glare. The most feared future Big East team, they have made every current conference team pee their pants with the mention of their name.


She has hosted multiple cooking shows and seems to start a new one every few years. TCU has been a part of multiple athletics conferences and seems to join a new one every few years.

Alex is always seated at the center of the table, commanding the most respect. TCU will be sitting at the head of the Big East table for the next 25 years. Unless they leave to join the Pac-12 before then.